Please login to reply
|
|||||
[#98863]
Written by: kernelkertz [14/07/2008, 10:14] |
|||||
wtf!!!!!... there actually people that didn't know it then!!!! amazing. i can hear mcnulty saying "the bigger the lie the more people are willing to believe it" s5 was great by the way. |
|||||
[#98869]
Written by: HotStuff2 [14/07/2008, 11:24] |
|||||
i'm a "him". lol the term "hotstuff" comes from my eod (explosive ordinance disposal) days, when the call was "hotstuff coming through!" so people would make way to allow us to pass. no, marines nor any other branch are really "like" that. the racism they were showing is pure bs; he'd be getting his ass kicked in about .03 seconds by the rest of the platoon. soldiers don't see any other color than green, and you learn that in boot camp. i still don't see color (race-wise) to this day, unless it's some gang-banger wanna-be (any skin color), then i just laugh at 'em. the stealing from the people; well, the lt should have said something. his lack of doing so is implicitly condoning his soldier's actions, and i'm betting wll be a focal point later on. his covering up for the men who were cooking illegally in their tent? now that was realistic. you cya and that of your men. no commendations though; that comment was because the co *knew* the lt was lying. lol the part about them reading the little girl's letter bothered me; if that was based on a real account, then every soldier who watches this should be ashamed and outraged, as i was. i received many an anonymous letter from shool children, and no matter who it's from, letters from america are welcome and often read and re-read. it keeps the men in touch with why they're there and what they have to go home to. making sexual comments about a 10(ish)-year-old girl was just disgusting, and was simply pandering imho to the audience who seems to "expect" that from soldier shows. you can tell that these men have never been in a firefight or a conflict; their eagerness shows their youth. war is not cool, and seeing your buddies legs blown off is a sobering reality. having to carry your legless buddy hundreds of yards to a medevac, which taking small-arms fire, makes you realize you don't want to be there, and you don't want to be next. as for the "shoot the dog" scene, that was actually common; iraqi soldiers would force dogs to swallow grenades and/or ieds, and then remotely blow them when the dogs got close to a group of soldiers who fed it. same with small children. i saw both of those on several occassions. you learn to be very distrustful of anything that moves. but, it's definitely watchable. i agree, however, the characters are tired cliches of what we see all the time in "military" shows. |
|||||
[#98871]
Written by: YourMomma59 [14/07/2008, 12:02] |
|||||
did you watch "over there" when it was on? i loved that show. from what i've heard of this one, i don't think i want to watch it. i hate the war, but i support our real soldiers. from what i'm able to assess of the navy guys where i live, a lot of them chose the life because they wanted to get out of their little podunk town, out of poverty, because there were no other jobs to be had, because they couldn't afford college. i know so many navy guys who the think our president is a slimy, vermin idiot it's not funny. the problem with our military is they are basically paid slaves. they aren't allowed to speak out when they think the president is being an asshole and their ability to function well as a unit requires them to do everything they are told. consequently, if a jerk is leading them...you get my drift. yes, i hate our country for conning weak-minded people into invading iraq, but that's why our government treats it's citizens so badly (regarding health care, making sure people have a roof over their heads and food to eat). if we were all equal in our country, the power mongers would have no one to control and they are too weak to survive on their own. it's not about oil, it's about the greedy power elite and their fear of losing their power. |
|||||
[#98880]
Written by: HotStuff2 [14/07/2008, 15:12] |
|||||
watch that. this one isn't bad, but it's some of the same old trite the public "expects" to see. lots of military men and women joined for the reasons you mentioned; so did i. i ended up doing great things, and don't regret it for one second. i miss it most days (fyi, i'm a disabled vet, and was medically discharged, as i broke my back in a halo jump accident.) ever watch "black hawk down"? i was in the second wave of rangers that went in that night, oct. 10 1993. that's where i got my 2nd purple heart; i took shrapnet to my chest, which pierced my flak vest and penetrated my lung. i pulled it out, patched myself up, and moved out to cintinue the mission, like a good ranger should. yes, bush is an idiot. he should never have one in the first place, much less the second time. only the second president in the history of the us to lose the popular vote, yet win the electorial college vote and get the presidency. :rolleyes: obama doesn't have a shot; mccain does. forget race, forget all that bs. mccain is pro-military, and that's why i support him. when i was serving, we were poverty-level, even with base housing (which took *forever* to get, and only after my first purple heart did i get pumped up the list), and for what the lower enlisted do, the pay is far too low. one of the many reasons i loved clinton; he was a great president (bjs or not), and he supported pay increases for lower enlisted soldiers. i met him twice, shook his hand both times, and he genuinely cared about hearing what the soldiers had to say. but i digress, and this is way off topic. |
|||||
[#98892]
Written by: timothycrash [14/07/2008, 17:24] |
|||||
@ joedbone: while these guys fight in a volunteer army, but under *orders* from their superiors, you get to jack off at the computer, downloading free tv shows from the internet - all in the comfort of your mom's basement. if you have a problem with the war, get off your lazy ass and do something about it...jackass. oh ya, brother, there are many things you could be doing other than condemning the soldiers in this war on a message board. some people's kids. |
|||||
[#98904]
Written by: Andysays [14/07/2008, 18:15] |
|||||
[#98906]
Written by: Andysays [14/07/2008, 18:17] |
|||||
those paying attention know that mccain does not support the military (at least not in his votes in the senate), and just last week he got called on this by a vet in colorado. in response to this vet, mccain lied about his vet voting record several times. but like bush said one, you have to repeat things (lies) several times to "catapult the propaganda." and if obama has "no chance," why is he leading in every poll by well over the margin of error? mccain is a terrible candidate. he's lucky that the media love him so much that they ignore much (all though not all) of his ineptitude. |
|||||
[#98963]
Written by: Billy Nick [15/07/2008, 04:18] |
|||||
it's a shame that a tv show can generate so much hatred towards soldiers who risk their lives to do what they are doing. they don't have a choice what wars to go into or what country they are sent to, they go because they are told. imagine america or britain with soldiers who pick and choose what wars or countries they go to. i am a brit and i am against the war in iraq but i am 100% in support of british and american troops over there. if people want to slag anyone off they should be slagging off the polititions and not the soldiers that are risking their lives for doing their jobs. |
|||||
[#98967]
Written by: HotStuff2 [15/07/2008, 05:13] |
|||||
just a message to billy: when i was in iraq and somalia, i had the extreme pleasure of working with several british sas soldiers. regardless of the country, they were our brothers, and we looked out for each other (heck, we got drunk after hours on more than one occassion lol.) great bunch of guys, tough as hell, and man, could they drink! |
|||||
[#98970]
Written by: joedbone [15/07/2008, 05:40] |
|||||
to be honest, i wasn\'t condemning anyone, just taking the piss out of the crassness of the show.. i was surprised not to get many more responses like timothycrash, though. for the record, nobody in iraq is doing my job - be they islamic extremists, occupying imperialist armies or civilians - i\'m a commie, so i want world revolution to smash capitalism - and i don\'t want the world dragged back to feudal times by the fundamentalists on either side... the show got better towards the end though, didn\'t it? |
|||||
[#99118]
Written by: kernelkertz [16/07/2008, 09:32] |
|||||
the soldiers are only doing what they are trained to do. except for some. it takes far more courage to say "sir, no, sir!" than to blindly follow orders imho. the winter soldiers are my heroes. http://www.sirnosir.com/ - great film |
|||||
[#99268]
Written by: mcbrite [17/07/2008, 23:43] |
|||||
well, isn't the purple heart for getting wounded? sounds to me more like a consolation-prize... ;-d |
|||||
[#99269]
Written by: mcbrite [17/07/2008, 23:50] |
|||||
you obviously never watched liveleak... ;-d |
|||||
[#99492]
Written by: Rapax [20/07/2008, 23:50] |
|||||
the series is based on the real events when 1st recon entered iraq in 2003. i think the embedded author and marines would have noticed if an ied had gone off and mentioned it in the book. besides, why should there be an ied when they had barely even entered iraq? ieds became a daily occurance once the occupation started, not right at the start of the invasion. there's nothing unrealistic about that. |
|||||
[#100213]
Written by: demondiablo [28/07/2008, 08:32] |
|||||
i'm a little late to comment here but i just wanted to say that i agree with you. when i read hotstuffs comments i dont believe i could've found a more disillusioned person of the facts. fact is obama has a better voting record with supporting the troops than mccain does. fact is obama is more supported and endorsed by military advisment committees than mccain is. your doing yourself a great disservice if you think that just because mccain is a veteran like you, that he sympathises more with you than obama does. do yourself a favor and stop assuming and do some research on the matter. that said i just watched ep 1 and 2 and am now dl'ing 3. i thought they were both pretty good episodes. i think when viewing though you have to take everything with a grain of salt. nothing is a %100 accurate. hbo gots bills to pay after all. |
|||||